Curl BC will be discussing this weekend the first draft of the following proposal to change BC’s playdown system. They are encouraging input from curlers in the coming weeks as modifications to the proposal are made.
Background
Curling has changed since BC and many of the other provincial and territorial curling associations created their playdowns and provincial championship processes. The two areas most dramatically affected are those that are now universally considered as performance (as opposed to participation) events. Primarily due to the Olympics and the great success of the World Curling Tour, these two championships are increasingly focused on the elite curler and the players and teams that are willing to make the commitment to become world champions and Olympians.
It is therefore essential that Curl BC change its qualification criteria and processes to recognize this new paradigm. We must provide dedicated athletes with a better opportunity to play top competition on a regular basis in British Columbia; we must recognize what it takes for British Columbia teams to be competitive on the world stage; and we must ensure our playdown processes assist in creating and developing teams that can compete at other levels.
With this dramatic change in the performance end of curling, we must also fill the competitive gap for the other curlers in the province who, due to a multitude of circumstances, are unable to commit the time or resources to compete as this level. For those curlers, we will need to further build The Dominion Curling Club Championship, the BC Club Challenge, and regional curling tours that provide opportunities for the “participation” competitors in the province.
Eligibility
For the men and women’s competitions, regional composition or residency requirements will disappear. Teams can be composed of any players of eligible age that reside within the province of British Columbia (residency to be verified by a valid healthcare card, driver’s license and/or passport with a BC address) and are paid up curlers at an affiliated curling club (to be verified by the curling club and submission of the names on the active curlers list).
Teams must also be registered with the Canadian Team Ranking System (CTRS) – something which has no cost associated to it.
Teams choosing to be eligible will also be required to pay a combined CCA and Curl BC competitor’s fee.
Provincial Championships
For now the provincial championship will retain their existing format – 10 team round robin. However, it remains to be determined if the finals round is a three team playoff or a four team page playoff. The provincial championships will continue to be televised with the intent to increase coverage and to elevate them to become more significant revenue generating properties for Curl BC and host committees without increasing overall direct costs to the teams participating.
However, the ten teams at the provincial championships will no longer be based on regional numbers or a division between the interior and coastal regions of the province. The objective will be to have the 10 best teams in the province competing at the provincial championship.
The teams will qualify as follows:
- the defending provincial champion;
- the top eligible BC team on the Order of Merit;
- the top finishing BC team that has not already qualified (as long as they finish in the top four) in each of five qualifying events held around the province; and
- the next three teams in total current CTRS points (BC events, other Canadian events and world events) as calculated from January 1 to December 30th of the year proceeding the provincial championship (i.e., if the provincial championship is February 15, 2011 then the calculation will be based on points earned between January 1, 2010 and December 30, 2010).
Specific criteria will be defined to establish order of precedence to ensure that 10 teams will be participating in the provincial championship. It is likely that in each year, it will be more than the next three teams in CTRS points qualifying as there is likely to be duplications arising from the other qualifying criteria.
Details will still have to be worked out on potential tie-breaking for the final spots in the provincials but by using elements such as current year’s CTRS points, Order of Merit standings and working down to the number of BC cash qualifier events entered and the number of wins in those events, a clear system of qualifiers can be defined at the detail level.
Standard existing CTRS rules regarding how a team carries points forward will be used.
Direct Qualifying Events
There will be five qualifying events held around the province as follows:
- one hosted in Regions 1 / 2
- one hosted in Regions 5 / 6
- one hosted in Regions 3 / 4 / 7
- one hosted in Regions 8 / 9 / 10; and
- one hosted in Region 11.
These will be structured as full CTRS events requiring a minimum of 16 teams in a men’s event and 12 team’s in a women’s event. The events will be scheduled from September to December. There will be no restrictions on the number of registered BC teams that can enter the event. They will be planned as triple knockouts but if the number of entries exceeds the planned schedule, the events may be reduced to double knockouts. If any event does not satisfy the minimum entry criteria to be registered as a CTRS event, the event will be cancelled and the berth that would have been available through the event will become available to the next top CTRS points qualifier.
Event entry fees will be set at a minimum of $500 per team with the entire entry fee being returned to the competitors through the prize pool for each event. Teams are allowed to enter as many events as they choose even if they have already qualified. Non-eligible provincial championship teams are also able to enter these events (i.e., teams that are not CTRS registered or who have not paid the competitors fee) as in any cash event which will allow for increased CTRS points through the strength of field multiplier.
The cash prize pool for the qualifiers will help to offset the costs for the winning teams at the provincial championships as Curl BC will no longer provide travel or per diem expense money to attend provincial championships. An accommodation subsidy will be available to teams that stay at sponsor hotels during a provincial event. The following table shows the potential winnings that teams will be able to earn as they enter and qualify through these Curl BC cash qualifiers to get to provincial championships.
Existing CTRS events in the provincial will be able to apply to become a Curl BC cash qualifying event. However, this would mean that they could not have any restriction or limitation on the number of BC teams entering the event. Events can be hosted at clubs and in areas as revenue generators and to promote curling in that area.